Estuary News

June 2021

Bay Trail Retreat at Bothin Marsh

The Bay Trail connecting Sausalito and Mill Valley is a bustling pathway where recreational bicyclists, bike commuters, and pedestrians all mix amidst the bayfront marsh scenery of the Bothin Marsh Open Space Preserve. Around thirty times per year, though, this scene looks dramatically different, as high tides flood the area with seawater, making the path impassable.

Experts say this demonstrates how vulnerable the path and marsh are to sea-level rise, and an ambitious new project is underway to re-engineer the pathway and help the marsh adapt to this future. On June 8, the team working on this “Evolving Shorelines” project announced a final design that moves the Bay Trail to follow the perimeter of the marsh, but the decision didn’t come easy.

Bay Trail realignment. Map: ESA/WRT

“It was evident that the multiuse path is our most-used park asset, and it’s extremely visible to the public,” said Veronica Pearson, ecological restoration planner with Marin County Parks and part of the One Tam team leading the project. “And we wanted to be very conscious about how we develop the plan for adaptation and keep the public in the loop.”

In partnership with Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy, the project team has sought community input and guidance from the start. Indeed, this stretch of the Bay Trail is so popular that addressing its vulnerability to sea-level rise makes a great launchpad for conversations about climate change adaptation and the role of tidal marsh ecosystems. These ecosystems not only provide habitat for wildlife, they also act as natural water-filtration systems between the land and Bay waters and sequester and store large amounts of carbon. 

The rising Bay isn’t a concern for the distant future; experts project a foot of increase in Marin by 2030, producing flooding events around 220 days per year. The one-foot increase would submerge the mudflats and shift the high-tide line closer to the road and communities, subjecting businesses and homes along Shoreline Highway to frequent flooding. By the turn of the century, impacts will be far worse.

The project team plans to take on the most urgent adaptations first, such as resurfacing the Bay Trail to maintain functionality for recreation and transportation. Walking or biking along the trail today, one can already see the corrosive effects of flooding seawater evident in the trail’s pocked surface. Project leaders also plan to create raised marsh mounds and improve connectivity to tidal channels, which will not only preserve quality wildlife habitat but also help the marsh adapt to the shorter-term impacts of sea-level rise up to about two feet. Ultimately, however, planners seek to prepare for up to four feet of rise by 2060.

Predicted Sea Level Rise Impacts on Bothin Marsh. Source: ESA/WRT

Although the rich biodiversity of the marsh gives the feeling that it predates the human development surrounding it, the truth is that this area has undergone extensive changes over the last 150 years. In 1851, most of what is now marsh was actually open water. Significant engineering changes began in 1924 in order to support first a railroad bridge, and later a berm. The Bay Trail of today follows the footprint of this old railroad berm. This was followed by a 1960s flood-control project that rerouted Coyote Creek, impacting sediment supply to the marsh from the watershed.

All this engineering means that the natural processes that would sustain the marsh into the future aren’t in place, including a restoring flow of sediment needed to counteract erosive wave action. Despite these human impacts, the marsh habitat has become a vibrant habitat for wildlife and plants, offering views of acrobatic dives of Caspian terns alongside the more slow-moving elegance of Black-necked stilts as they forage in the mudflats.

Alternate Adaptation Concepts. Source: ESA/WRT

In October 2020, the project team presented three different trail alignment options to the public and explained related impacts to Coyote Creek. On June 8 of this year, following community input, the team announced the favored plan, which realigns the Bay Trail to follow the perimeter of the marsh. The design leaves the old trail embankment in place to create new, higher marsh habitat for wildlife and provides a buffer between the shoreline and waves coming from Richardson Bay.

A new raised embankment along the marsh perimeter offers higher ground for the trail, flanked by an ecotone slope (vegetated transitional habitat), as well as a buffer between the road and community and the high tides. Without the bisecting trail in the way, the plan allows the marsh to undergo a more natural adaptation process. The project is still in the planning and permitting stage, with implementation slated for 2025.

As excited as the project team is to tackle such a big challenge and test some of these adaptation techniques, Rob LaPorte, project manager with Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy, emphasized that we can’t miss the forest for the trees. “Slowing the pace of sea-level rise is critical to giving the marsh its best chance of survival: the slower the rate, the better opportunity the marsh will have to adapt. It’s a good reminder that climate mitigation and reducing carbon emissions are still our biggest tools to reducing impacts to our environment.”

Prior Estuary News Stories

12-County Sea Level Rise Adaptation Action, June 2020

Other Links

One Tam Bothin Marsh

One Tam Evolving Shorelines

Top Photo: Bay Trail vision view adjacent to Almonte Boulevard, Bothin Marsh, Marin County. Rendering: ESA/WRT

About the author

Elyse writes about wildlife ecology and environmental science for Estuary. Her background as a wildlife biologist often leads her to stories about the joys of scientific discovery and the ways that people interact with, and about, the environment. She currently writes from a floating abode in the San Francisco Bay, where the neighbors occasionally nest on her roof. Some of her writing and photography can be found here.

Related Posts

American Avocet on managed, former salt ponds in the South Bay. Photo: Roopak Bhatt, USGS

One-of-a-Kind Stories

Our magazine’s media motto for many years has been “Where there’s an estuary, there’s a crowd.” The San Francisco Estuary is a place where people, wildlife, and commerce congregate, and where watersheds, rivers and the ocean meet and mix, creating a place of unusual diversity. In choosing to tell the...
dam spillway oroville

Supplying Water

Ever since the state and federal water projects were built in the 1930s and 1940s, California has captured snowmelt in foothill reservoirs, and moved the fresh water from dam releases and river outflows to parched parts of the state via aqueducts hundreds of miles long. A convoluted system of ancient...

Tackling Pollution

Though the Clean Water Act did an amazing job of reducing wastewater and stormwater pollution of the San Francisco Estuary, some contaminants remain thorny problems.  Legacy pollutants like mercury washed into the watershed from upstream gold mining, PCBs from old industrial sites, and selenium from agricultural drainage in the San...